Kraft paper tape roll beside folded kraft box blanks, a printed paper tape and embossed paper wrap on a dark packing table

BOPP tape vs kraft paper tape, which one should seal your cartons?

For most cartons, BOPP tape is still the cheaper and safer choice. It costs less per carton, it shrugs off humidity, and it holds on almost any board. Kraft paper tape is the better choice when your box has to go into paper recycling as one piece, when your customer has asked for plastic-free packaging, or when you want a seal that clearly shows tampering.

We make both on our own lines in Jaipur, so I have no reason to push one over the other.

I would rather you buy the right one.

The two tapes in one paragraph each

BOPP tape is a thin film of biaxially oriented polypropylene (plastic stretched in two directions) coated with adhesive. Our standard BOPP tapes run from 36 to 70 micron in total thickness. It is the clear or brown tape you see on almost every carton in India.

Kraft paper tape is a strip of brown kraft paper with an adhesive on one side. It comes in two very different types. Self-adhesive kraft tape works like normal tape, from a normal hand dispenser. Gummed kraft tape (also called water-activated tape) has a dry glue that only becomes sticky when it is wetted, usually by a gummed tape dispenser.

Most of the confusion I see comes from mixing up these two.

Side by side

Point BOPP tape Self-adhesive kraft tape Gummed (water-activated) kraft tape
Base Polypropylene film Kraft paper Kraft paper
Standard roll we supply 48 mm x 65 m 48 mm x 50 m Made to order
Dispenser Any hand or machine dispenser Any hand dispenser Needs a water-activated dispenser
Grip on dusty recycled board Good with the right adhesive Fair, the adhesive sits on the surface Very good, the glue soaks into the fibres
Humid godown or monsoon Not affected by moisture Paper softens if it gets wet Paper softens if it gets wet
Tamper evidence Can be peeled and reapplied with care Tears when peeled Tears the carton surface when peeled
Printing your logo Yes, up to 8 colours on our lines Yes Yes
Recycling with the carton Plastic is screened out at the paper mill Goes into paper recycling with the box Goes into paper recycling with the box
Cost per metre Lowest Higher Higher, plus the dispenser

Cost per carton, worked out

Tape is bought per roll but used per carton.

So compare cost per carton, not price per roll.

Take a common carton of 400 x 300 x 300 mm with a single strip on top and bottom (an I-seal), and 60 mm of tape running down each end.

  1. Tape per face is 400 + 60 + 60 = 520 mm.
  2. Top and bottom together use 1.04 m.
  3. A 65 m BOPP roll seals about 62 cartons. A 50 m kraft roll seals about 48.

So even at the same price per roll, paper tape costs about 30% more per carton, simply because the roll is shorter. On top of that, kraft tape usually costs more per metre than BOPP, so the real gap is wider. Use your own quotes in the same three steps and you will have a fair number.

Two more costs people forget. A shorter roll means more roll changes per shift. And gummed tape needs a dispenser, which is a one-time cost, but it often lets you use one strip where BOPP needed two.

Strength: a different kind of strong

BOPP film is strong in tension and stretches a little before it breaks. That stretch helps when a heavy carton is dropped or squeezed. For heavy and export cartons we normally suggest 45 to 55 micron with an H-seal, as I explained in our BOPP tape micron guide.

Paper does not stretch.

If the edge of a kraft strip gets a small nick, it can tear along the width. So for heavy cartons I would not use thin self-adhesive kraft tape on its own.

Gummed tape is a different case. Once the glue is wet, it soaks into the carton fibres and dries as part of the box. If someone tries to pull it, the carton surface tears with it. That is why many export and high-value shippers like it. The seal does not lift at the ends in summer, and nobody can open it quietly.

Humidity, cold and dust

This is where BOPP wins clearly.

The film does not absorb water. Paper does. On our own kraft paper tape page we say plainly that paper tape is not waterproof, and for wet or very humid storage we recommend BOPP.

In north Indian winters, any self-adhesive tape grabs slowly on a cold carton. Press it firmly. Gummed tape needs the right amount of water, and a dispenser left with a dirty brush or old water gives weak seals.

Dusty, soft recycled board is hard on every self-adhesive tape. Gummed tape handles it best because the glue goes into the fibres instead of sitting on the dust.

Recycling: the honest picture

A corrugated box is pulped at a paper mill. Paper tape goes into the pulp with the box. Plastic tape does not dissolve. The mill screens it out with other rejects, and the waste goes to landfill or fuel. So if your customer puts the box in paper recycling without peeling the tape, kraft tape is the cleaner choice.

The kraft paper backing itself is biodegradable and compostable. But please do not tell your customers that paper tape is "plastic-free" in every sense without checking. Self-adhesive kraft tape still carries an adhesive layer. Ask any supplier what the adhesive is before you print a claim on your box.

BOPP is polypropylene and can be recycled as plastic, but only if it is collected as plastic.

Stuck to a carton, it almost never is.

"I do not tell every customer to switch to paper tape. If your cartons sit in a damp godown for three months, BOPP will serve you better. Paper tape makes sense when the whole box goes for paper recycling and your buyer cares about it."

Dr. Piyush Singhal, CEO, Jagannath Polymers

When to use which

  1. Use BOPP tape for general cartons, heavy cartons, cold chain, damp storage, and any line that uses carton sealing machines.
  2. Use self-adhesive kraft tape for ecommerce boxes, gift and retail boxes, and brands selling a plastic-free unboxing, with light to medium weights.
  3. Use gummed kraft tape for export cartons, high-value goods that need tamper evidence, and shippers who pack enough boxes a day to justify a dispenser.
  4. Use both if you need to. Many companies keep BOPP for master cartons going into storage and kraft tape for the boxes that reach the final customer.

If your box is already plastic-free inside, with honeycomb paper wrap or paper void fill, a strip of BOPP on top undoes part of the story. That is the main reason ecommerce brands switch.

Mistakes we see often

  1. Buying self-adhesive kraft tape for heavy, dusty recycled cartons and blaming the tape when it lifts.
  2. Storing paper tape rolls in a damp godown. The rolls absorb moisture before they are ever used.
  3. Using kraft tape on glossy laminated or plastic-coated boxes. Gummed tape bonds poorly or not at all on such surfaces.
  4. Comparing roll prices without noticing that one roll is 50 m and the other is 65 m.

FAQ

Is kraft paper tape stronger than BOPP tape?

Not in a simple pull test. BOPP film is stronger in tension. Gummed kraft tape gives a stronger seal on corrugated board because it bonds into the fibres.

Can I use kraft tape in my normal tape dispenser?

Self-adhesive kraft tape, yes. Gummed tape, no. It needs a water-activated dispenser.

Do I need to remove kraft tape before recycling a carton?

No. Paper tape goes into paper recycling with the box. Plastic tape should be peeled off where possible.

We supply BOPP tapes (plain and printed) and kraft paper tapes in bulk for India and export. For a few rolls to test, our online store PackSmith sells small packs. For bulk, send us your carton size, weight and storage conditions through the contact page, and we will suggest the tape and send samples. Our full BOPP range is on the BOPP tapes page.

Request a Quote